Twilight the Book’s Bella and Twilight the Movie’s Bella
I just watched the movie of Twilight (I loved it – I’m such a romantic, such a pushover) – and our heroine, Bella, is a different person than the Bella from the book.
She’s evolved, stronger, more receptive.
And the difference in the two ways of seeing this character can be a huge help to us, here.
In the book (and remember – Bella as a character is 17, but she speaks for the girl in all of us) – Bella is headstrong, argumentative, feels unworthy and so she’s defensive. She fights falling for Edward, and every step of the way, she fights him. She fights him wanting to carry her up a hill. She fights him taking her anywhere or giving her anything or doing anything for her. She fights against love in all kinds of ways.
And so her surrender to Edward – allowing him to carry her up a hill, allowing him to give to her (she rails against his rescuing of her, saying that she “wants to be the superhero sometimes”) – as all the more powerful.
In the film, Bella is so clearly brave, warm, loving, strong, smart and feels so much more worthy (they leave in just a few moments of insecurity) that her surrender has a different quality. It seems natural, and more girlish.
The Bella of the book feels to me more like a woman who has a bit of a “chip on her shoulder” – and so she’s easier to identify with.
The Bella of the book is more “flawed” than the Bella of the movie.
The Bella of the book has more fear of closeness and intimacy and of RECEIVING than she does of death. She’d rather be in CONTROL than anything else. And so, surrendering to love feels huge – and we’re a bit frustrated at how difficult it is for her.
Also, in the book, she strategizes. She tries to get information out of others through cleverness, even lying – where the movie Bella is upfront, honest, straightforward.
The book Bella is a misfit, a girl who never had even a date with a boy and always felt out of place. You believe her when she says she’s not pretty. Even though I knew the beautiful Kristen Stewart plays her in the movie – as I read, I pictured the book Bella as regular-looking. I believed that she was not beautiful.
The movie Bella is the most beautiful girl anyone’s ever seen, the moment she shows up. There is no way she could be insecure. Unconventional, perhaps, but not insecure.
It was harder for me to identify with the movie Bella, because, though she was constantly amazed by what was happening, she didn’t doubt Edward’s feelings for her.
In the book, Bella doubts his feelings constantly. In fact, she asks him how and why he feels about her constantly. AND – he constantly TELLS her. He never seems to mind all her questioning. He seems to find her insecurity charming.
In the book, Bella is so contemptuous of being the “damsel in distress” that she behaves stupidly and BECOMES the damsel in distress.
In the movie, she allows Edward to rescue her with grace, and so she BECOMES a superhero herself. Her bravery is evident and on purpose – unlike the book Bella’s headstrong and, well, sometimes actually obnoxious self-righteousness and resistance to everything. She’s like someone you take to Disneyland who complains about the rides.
In the movie, Bella has a sense of wonder, and she trusts Edward because she believes in HERSELF. She is actually not afraid. Bella in the book is often pretending to not be afraid – and so she’s “contrary” to cover it up.
So – the director of the film and the actress who played Bella saw the problems in the book Bella, and evolved her.
And…strangely enough…I MISSED the book Bella as i was watching the film.
I wanted to BE like the movie Bella, but I FELT more like the book Bella.
I, as a flawed person, had difficulty identifying with the non-flawed Bella. I know it had nothing to do with age…both of these characters are sort of “timeless.” Some of it has to do with the joy of reading – you get to infuse the characters with images from your own mind in heart. In a movie – there are real people up there.
So – the movie Bella seemed like a leap to me.
I am all about starting from where you are. That’s what “Riffing” is all about – starting from where you are and what you feel – NOW.
So, let’s look at the leap WE want to make – from Doing defensive, run by old patterns, afraid of intimacy, blocked from receiving love and gestures of caring and even help and rescue “things” – to Being soft, available, open, strong inside, confident, and willing to let an amazing man love us, without questioning our worth.
How to get there?
1. Start HERE. You are where you are. Take stock. If the most amazing man in the world showed up and wanted you…how would you feel? How would you act? Imagine it. Feel all the “good” and “not-so-good” feelings.
2. Now imagine you have utter confidence, you see him as a person just like yourself, you believe in your strengths and your fabulous qualities, you are a movie heroine, you are fearless, you are filled with wonder, you can handle surprise, you can make decisions, you are your own superhero, you are your own rescuer, and you can allow this man to rescue you, too.
Go ahead and have fun with this. Let the fantasy take you, and if it starts to take you backwards – into a memory of what might have been once, or an old story – pull yourself out and throw yourself forward into this new fantasy where you are “evolved.” Where you are where you WANT to be.
Let me know what that looks like for you.
Love, Rori
written by Rori Raye • Permalink • Comments (48) • Leave a Comment »



